All right, folks, we’ve got a real doozy to take a look at today, an actual genuine honest to goodness WAR PICTURE from the folks at MTI.
If you’re worried right now, you’re not alone. MTI has, as I’ve said in the past, always been a feast or famine sort of studio. When they’re good they can do amazing things, but when they’re bad, they outright suck. Always the question with an MTI movie will be, is this going to be great, or will it be horrible?
Today’s choice, Brother’s War, proves to be mostly horrible.
Based on a true story, Brother’s War features a British solider attached to the Red Army who discovers that the Russians have been committing war crimes against the Polish government-in-exile. Naturally, the Russians don’t want this getting around, so Stalin’s intelligence service, feared throughout the Soviet Union, is dispatched to capture the British soldier. Naturally, they catch him, and lock him up with a German captain. The Brit and the German both share something important, however–they’re both Freemasons. When they escape, along with a nurse named Anna, they’re pursued by the Russians, in desperate hope of extinguishing the secret that the three now carry with them that could irrevocably alter the world.
So no, these are not actual brothers you’ll be hearing about, but rather the figurative brotherhood of Freemasonry. Say what you will about them–and pretty much everything that can be said has been said–they consider themselves (or at least these two do) to be as thoroughly brothers as any blood relative.
It’s hard to call a movie with regular amounts of gunfire and explosions boring, but somehow, Brother’s War manages to be exactly that. The tension created by the suspenseful scenes was minimal at best, and the action sequences fell flat due to a lack of coherence. The scenes in the Russian prison suffer from a horrendous excess of acting, though sadly, not acting SKILL. Watching the German escape was particularly sad as the interrogator managed to go down just by the German swinging his fist in front of him. I know, it’s supposed to be a punch, but it definitely didn’t look like one. It’s as though someone forgot to include basic stage combat courses in the curriculum for these actors. And the escapes aren’t that much better, really–the whole thing comes off as lacking.
Frankly, there wasn’t much exciting going on here. And that’s a particular insult if this is actually based on a true story, because I’m pretty sure the ACTUAL affair was vastly more exciting and vastly more terrifying than this sad little wreck was.
About the only high point of this misery was the background music. They really went all out with the strange Russian psuedo-hymns–you ever heard the Red Army Choir sing the national anthem? That’s the kind of thing I’m hearing on this one. It’s got a weird kind of eerie grace to it, and that’s what you’ll be hearing in the background throughout Brother’s War, should you actually decide to subject yourself to it. Though I will admit that the second half is somewhat better than the first, it, much like war itself, isn’t really worth what you had to go through to get there.
The Screenhead Ten Scale gives Brother’s War a three out of ten for being only an occasional auditory pleasure, and failing to remember that it’s supposed to be a movie rather than a soundtrack.




